How do solar pergolas compare to solar roof panels in terms of efficiency?

Solar pergolas generally offer lower efficiency than roof-mounted panels due to design constraints and environmental factors. However, their performance depends heavily on installation quality, panel angle, and sun exposure. In the UK, roof panels typically achieve better efficiency because they’re easier to install at optimal angles (20°–50° south-facing), while pergolas often require additional mounting hardware to meet these angles.

---

Key Efficiency Factors

• Angle and orientation: Roof panels are frequently installed at ideal angles for UK sunlight exposure. Pergolas with flat or slightly tilted roofs (common in UK gardens) may require tilt mounts to reach 20°–50° angles, which adds complexity and cost.
• Shading: Pergolas in gardens are more prone to shading from trees, buildings, or furniture, reducing panel output by up to 25% in suboptimal setups.
• Cooling: Rooftop panels often benefit from better airflow beneath them, preventing overheating. Pergola panels may lack this airflow, especially if installed flush to the structure.

---

Real-World UK Applications

• Pergola systems: Three to five panels on a pergola can power outdoor lighting, electronics, or garden tools, saving around £70 annually. Larger setups (up to 10 panels) may partially power a home during peak sunlight.
• Roof systems: A 4kW rooftop array (about 12 panels) generates 1.3–1.6 tonnes of CO₂ savings annually, enough to cover most household needs.

---

Pros and Cons

Solar Pergolas

• Pros:
• Ideal for homes with unsuitable roofs (east-west orientation, shading, or weak structure).
• Doubles as shaded outdoor space.
• Ground-based systems can be up to 25% more efficient than some rooftop setups (if optimal angles are achieved).
• Cons:
• Costs £350–£500 per panel plus £300–£600 installation.
• Requires frequent cleaning due to dust/debris accumulation in gardens.
• May need planning permission if exceeding permitted development rules.

Solar Roof Panels

• Pros:
• Higher average efficiency due to standardized installation practices.
• Lower maintenance (less debris buildup compared to garden installations).
• Eligible for Smart Export Guarantee (SEG) payments for excess energy.
• Cons:
• Limited suitability for older roofs or heritage buildings.
• Requires structural assessment for homes with weak roofing.

---

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Ignoring angle adjustments can result in poor efficiency and increased dirt buildup. Use adjustable mounts.
2. Don't underestimate shading; trim overhanging branches and avoid placing pergolas near tall structures.
3. Overloading structures can be an issue since most UK pergolas support 10–15 panels (300–500kg total weight). Check load-bearing capacity first.

---

Policy and Cost Insights

• SEG eligibility: Roof installations typically qualify for SEG, while pergola systems may not unless connected to the main property’s supply.
• Recent cost trends: Pergola installations cost £2,100–£3,500 for a 3–5 panel system, compared to £6,000–£8,000 for a 4kW rooftop array.
• Efficiency benchmarks: Roof panels achieve 15–22% efficiency in the UK, while pergola systems often operate at 12–19% due to suboptimal mounting.

For most UK homeowners, rooftop panels remain the most efficient choice. However, solar pergolas provide a viable alternative for those prioritizing garden aesthetics or lacking suitable roof space.